The Fall of the House of Usher
Edgar Allan Poe
Contains spoilers for the entire book.
Discussion topics
Topic 01 of 08
The approach
The narrator feels an “insufferable gloom” at his very first sight of the house. How does Poe build dread before anything has happened?
Keep the conversation going
- What did you make of the faint crack running down the front of the house?
- Why do you think the narrator comes at all?
There is no single right answer. Bring your own reading.
Discussion topics
The narrator feels an “insufferable gloom” at his very first sight of the house. How does Poe build dread before anything has happened?
Keep the conversation going
- What did you make of the faint crack running down the front of the house?
- Why do you think the narrator comes at all?
Roderick’s senses are so acute that he can bear only bland food, dim light and a few sounds. How did you picture him?
Keep the conversation going
- Is his illness of the body, of the mind, or of the family itself?
- What do his paintings and music tell us about him?
Madeline passes through the story almost without a word. Why do you think Poe keeps her so silent and so distant?
Keep the conversation going
- What is the bond between the twins?
- How did you read her return at the end?
The local peasants use the name “House of Usher” for both the family and the mansion. How far are the two the same thing in the story?
Keep the conversation going
- Does the house cause the family’s decline, or reflect it?
- What do you make of the house’s final collapse into the tarn?
Roderick sings a poem about a fair palace overrun by evil things. Why do you think Poe places it in the middle of the story?
Keep the conversation going
- How does the poem mirror what is happening to Roderick?
- Did the change from prose to verse affect the mood for you?
Roderick decides to keep his sister’s body in a vault beneath the house for a fortnight. What did you suspect at this point?
Keep the conversation going
- Why does the narrator help, and what does he notice about Madeline’s face?
- How does Poe use the vault and its iron door to tighten the suspense?
On the night of the storm the narrator reads aloud from the “Mad Trist”, and its sounds seem to echo through the house. What effect did this have on you?
Keep the conversation going
- When did you realise what the sounds really were?
- Why might Roderick have kept silent about what he heard?
Everything comes to us through the narrator, who admits to catching some of Roderick’s fear. How much of the story do you believe happened as he tells it?
Keep the conversation going
- Is this a supernatural tale or a psychological one?
- Why do you think Poe leaves the question open?
There is no single right answer. Bring your own reading.

