North and South
Elizabeth Cleghorn Gaskell
Contains spoilers for the entire book.
Discussion topics
Topic 01 of 08
Leaving Helstone
What did you make of Mr Hale’s decision to leave the Church, and of his asking Margaret to break the news to her mother?
Keep the conversation going
- Is his crisis of conscience an act of courage, of weakness, or both?
- How does this first upheaval change Margaret’s place in her family?
There is no single right answer. Bring your own reading.
Discussion topics
What did you make of Mr Hale’s decision to leave the Church, and of his asking Margaret to break the news to her mother?
Keep the conversation going
- Is his crisis of conscience an act of courage, of weakness, or both?
- How does this first upheaval change Margaret’s place in her family?
How does Gaskell use Margaret’s first impressions of Milton, its smoke, its streets and its people, to set up the contrast between north and south?
Keep the conversation going
- Which of Margaret’s early judgements, such as her dislike of “shoppy people”, did you find hardest to forgive?
- Does the novel let either region come out clearly better than the other?
How do Thornton and Higgins each explain the strike, and whose account did you find more persuasive?
Keep the conversation going
- How does Boucher’s fate complicate the positions of both the union and the masters?
- What has Thornton learned from Higgins by the end, and how does it change the way he deals with his men?
What does Margaret’s friendship with Bessy give each of them?
Keep the conversation going
- How does Bessy’s love of the Book of Revelation help her bear her life, and what did you make of it?
- Why do you think Gaskell shows the cost of the mills through a slow illness rather than a sudden accident?
Why does Margaret step out in front of the crowd at Marlborough Mills, and why is she so ashamed afterwards of how it looked?
Keep the conversation going
- How did you respond to Thornton’s proposal the next day, and to Margaret’s refusal?
- What does the scene reveal about how a woman’s actions in public were read at the time?
Why does Margaret lie to the police inspector about being at Outwood station, and why does it weigh on her so heavily?
Keep the conversation going
- How does Thornton’s knowledge of the lie change what each of them thinks of the other?
- Is truthfulness the right standard to hold Margaret to, given what was at stake for her brother?
How does Margaret change as she loses, one after another, the people she has leaned on?
Keep the conversation going
- What did you make of her return to Helstone, and her discovery that it has changed too?
- Where does she find the strength to decide for herself how she will live?
How did you feel about the ending, in which Margaret, now Thornton’s landlord, comes to him with an offer that could save his mill?
Keep the conversation going
- Did their coming together feel earned after everything that has passed between them?
- What do the closing lines, with “That man!” and “That woman!”, suggest about the life ahead of them?
There is no single right answer. Bring your own reading.

