The Island of Doctor Moreau
H. G. Wells
Contains spoilers for the entire book.
Discussion topics
Topic 01 of 08
A story found among papers
Why do you think Wells frames the novel with an introduction by Prendick’s nephew, who cannot confirm a word of it?
Keep the conversation going
- How did the nephew’s note about Noble’s Isle and the missing schooner affect how much you believed Prendick?
- Does the framing make the story more frightening, or keep it at a safe distance?
There is no single right answer. Bring your own reading.
Discussion topics
Why do you think Wells frames the novel with an introduction by Prendick’s nephew, who cannot confirm a word of it?
Keep the conversation going
- How did the nephew’s note about Noble’s Isle and the missing schooner affect how much you believed Prendick?
- Does the framing make the story more frightening, or keep it at a safe distance?
Why does the sound of the puma in the locked enclosure disturb Prendick more than anything he has yet seen?
Keep the conversation going
- How does Wells use what Prendick hears but cannot see to build dread in the early chapters?
- What did you suspect was happening before Moreau explains himself?
Every line of the Law the Beast Folk chant ends with “Are we not Men?”: what did you make of that refrain?
Keep the conversation going
- Why does the Law hold the creatures only for as long as they fear the House of Pain?
- Did the Law remind you of any human codes, religions or systems of rule?
How did you respond to Moreau’s calm explanation, in Chapter XIV, that pain is a small matter and that he is trying to burn the animal out of his creatures?
Keep the conversation going
- Is he a monster, a scientist following his ideas to their end, or both?
- What does his indifference to pain say about the kind of science he stands for?
Montgomery is kind to Prendick and to M’ling, yet he has served Moreau for years: how did you judge him?
Keep the conversation going
- Why do you think he drinks, and what does his “Bank Holiday” with the Beast Folk reveal?
- Is he more to blame than Moreau, or less?
As the Beast Folk slip back towards the animal after Moreau’s death, what does the novel suggest about how deep anyone’s humanity goes?
Keep the conversation going
- Did your sympathy for the creatures grow or fade as the book went on?
- Where does Wells place the line between animal and human, if he places one at all?
How does Prendick survive his months alone with the Beast Folk, and what does it cost him?
Keep the conversation going
- What did you make of his decision to tell them that Moreau is not dead but watching them?
- How does living among them change the way he sees himself?
Back in London, Prendick cannot look at the people around him without seeing animals in their faces: how did you read this ending?
Keep the conversation going
- Is he damaged by what he has lived through, or has he seen something true?
- What comfort does he find in books, chemistry and the stars, and is it enough?
There is no single right answer. Bring your own reading.

